Insisting that ‘the country runs the risk of a CBN-induced recession’
The 36 States Governors in Nigeria have expressed displeasure at the hardship citizens were being subjected to by the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN)’s cash swap and cash limit policy.
The governor accused CBN Governor Godwin Emefiele of pursuing currency confiscation programme, not the currency exchange policy envisaged in the CBN Act.
They faulted the manner the CBN was going about its implementation of the cashless policy, describing it as draconian.
The Governors raised their concerns after a closed-door meeting held on February 11.
In communique issued after the meeting, signed by the NGF’s Chairman and Governor of Sokoto State, Aminu Tambuwal, available on Sunday, the nation’s 36 Governors asked the Federal Government and the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) to urgently comply with last week’s ruling by the Supreme Court and the advice by the Council of State on cash swap policy before irreversible harm is done to the nation’s economy.
The governors noted that despite the assurance by the Attorney General of the Federation (AGF) and Minister of Justice that the Fed Govt would comply with the Supreme Court’s ruling, the situation has not changed for the better.
The communique reads in parts:
“While we acknowledge the submission of the Attorney General of the Federation that the Federal Government will comply with the ruling of the Supreme Court, which calls for the halting of CBN’s plan to end the use of the old currency notes, we are yet to observe changes in the financial system.
“Consequently, we call on the Federal Government and the CBN to respect the rule of law and listen to the voice of reason expressed by Nigerians and several other stakeholders including the Council of State, before the damage to our economy becomes too great to fix by the next administration.
“Members rose from the meeting agreeing to direct their Attorneys General to review the suit at the Supreme Court with a view to consolidating the legal reliefs pursued by states.
“We express our sympathies and support with Nigerians who are experiencing great difficulties under the current CBN Naira re-design and cash withdrawal restrictions policy.
“We feel your pain and we are determined to employ all legitimate channels to ease the situation.
“The inability to use the new notes has had far-reaching economic effects, leading to the emergence of the Naira black market, severe food inflation, variable commodities prices based on the method of exchange, and long queues as well as crowds around Automated Teller Machines (ATMs) and banking halls across the country with individuals hoping to get a fraction of their money in new notes to meet their daily livelihood. The country runs the risk of a CBN-induced recession.
“It has become necessary to make a distinction between the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) Naira redesign policy backed by Section 20 (3) of the CBN Act, 2007 and the aspirational policy of going cashless, both of which are mutually exclusive at this time.
“It is our considered view that what the CBN is at present pursuing is a currency confiscation programme, not the currency exchange policy envisaged under S20(3) of the CBN Act 2007.
“Currency confiscation in the sense that the liquidity provided to the general public is grossly insufficient due to the restrictions placed on the amount that can be withdrawn regardless of the amount deposited.
“The current approach of the CBN raises concerns about the respect for the civil liberties and rights of Nigerians as it relates to their freedom to use legitimately earned income as they so wish.
“The forum believes that to deploy a cashless policy and deepen digital transactions, the best practice around the world is to create a suite of incentives to attract customers; rather than a draconian approach as we have witnessed in the last three months.
“The argument by the CBN for what it describes as the astronomical increase in the currency in circulation as the basis for this policy is not supported by its own data. According to the CBN, the currency in circulation increased from N1.4 trillion in 2015 to N3.23 trillion in October 2022.
“The bank (CBN) appears not to have taken into consideration the increase in the size of the country’s nominal GDP over this period, the doubling of consumer prices, rising population, and the impact of the humongous Ways & Means advances to the federal government by the Central Bank of Nigeria over this period.
“In the circumstances, it is safe to draw either of two conclusions – the CBN data may be incomplete or in fact, Nigerians may have done exceptionally well in the transition to a cashless economy.
“In addition, considering the sizeable informal sector in the nation, the amount of banknotes created in exchange so far by the CBN implies it vastly underestimated the economy’s actual cash needs.”
Discussion about this post