Saturday, July 5, 2025
  • Who’sWho Africa AWARDS
  • About Time Africa Magazine
  • Contact Us
Time Africa Magazine
  • Home
  • Magazine
  • WHO’SWHO AWARDS
  • News
  • World News
    • US
    • UAE
    • Europe
    • UK
    • Israel-Hamas
    • Russia-Ukraine
  • Politics
  • Crime
  • Lifestyle
  • Sports
  • Column
  • Interviews
  • Special Report
No Result
View All Result
Time Africa Magazine
  • Home
  • Magazine
  • WHO’SWHO AWARDS
  • News
  • World News
    • US
    • UAE
    • Europe
    • UK
    • Israel-Hamas
    • Russia-Ukraine
  • Politics
  • Crime
  • Lifestyle
  • Sports
  • Column
  • Interviews
  • Special Report
No Result
View All Result
Time Africa Magazine
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • WHO’SWHO AWARDS
  • News
  • Magazine
  • World News

Home » Featured » Will Senate President Akpabio Comply with the Court Order and Reinstate Akpoti-Uduaghan?

Will Senate President Akpabio Comply with the Court Order and Reinstate Akpoti-Uduaghan?

If the Senate President defies the ruling, it would signal a troubling erosion of institutional checks and balances. It could set Nigeria down a path where political loyalty overrides constitutional fidelity and where the rule of law becomes a casualty of expediency | By CHIDPETERS OKORIE

July 4, 2025
in Column, Featured
0
545
SHARES
4.5k
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

“Power concedes nothing without a demand. It never did and it never will.” — Frederick Douglass

On July 4, 2025, Justice Binta Nyako of the Federal High Court in Abuja delivered a landmark ruling: the Nigerian Senate’s six-month suspension of Senator Natasha Akpoti-Uduaghan was unlawful and undemocratic. The court demanded her immediate reinstatement—stripping the Senate of its authority to silence a voice and disenfranchise over 300,000 Kogi Central constituents.

This ruling arrives amidst a broader storm of allegations and constitutional doctrine —touching upon judicial supremacy, gendered power, and democratic legitimacy. As the Senate now stands at a fork in the road, the central question emerges: will Senate President Godswill Akpabio respect the court’s mandate, or will he challenge judicial authority and deepen Nigeria’s constitutional crises?

ReadAlso

Senator Natasha: Nigeria’s Senate President Akpabio Brought To Heel By Legal Checks

His Gamble: Why Godswill Akpabio Went All In Against Natasha Akpoti-Uduaghan

Akpoti-Uduaghan’s ordeal began on February 20, 2025. During the Senate’s plenary, she discovered her seat—critical for speaking rights—had been reassigned. When she protested, the Senate President denied her the floor, citing Senate rules. She countered with more: on Arise TV, she publicly accused Akpabio of sexual harassment dating back to December 2023. Though dismissed on a technicality, her petition reignited tensions. Instead of addressing her grievances, the Senate took disciplinary action—suspending her for speaking out of turn and refusing to accept her new seat. The six-month suspension drew extensive criticism for being politically motivated and excessive.

Legal heavyweights soon weighed in. Human rights lawyer Femi Falana (SAN) condemned the suspension as unconstitutional, referencing past rulings on Ali Ndume in 2017 and Ovie Omo-Agege in 2020 as precedents invalidating legislative suspensions exceeding 14 days. Legal experts echoed the sentiment: Senate Standing Order 67(4) limits suspensions to 14 days, making the six-month term a clear breach. These arguments center on constitutional supremacy and Article 4(8), which forbids laws inconsistent with the constitution.

ADVERTISEMENT

Justice Nyako’s ruling aligned with this legal reasoning, declaring both the Senate Rules and relevant clauses of the Legislative Houses, Powers & Privileges Act excessive. She emphasized that suspending a representative for 180 days—nearly the entire six-month cycle—effectively silenced Kogi Central’s voice.

Justice Nyako struck a delicate balance: while condemning the duration of the suspension, she did not dispute the Senate’s right to manage its affairs. The court affirmed that Akpabio was correct to withhold floor privileges because Akpoti-Uduaghan was not in her assigned seat. However, it declared the six-month duration excessive and undemocratic.

The court directed Akpabio to reconsider the punishment, immediately recall Akpoti-Uduaghan, and allow her return to the Senate—conditioned on an apology for not remaining in her assigned seat and for contempt.

On the contempt charge, Justice Nyako found that Akpoti-Uduaghan had violated an April 4 court order by posting a satirical Facebook letter on April 27, leading to a ₦5 million fine, a public apology in two national newspapers, and publication of the same apology on her Facebook page. She must comply within seven days.

At its core, this case challenges Nigeria’s separation of powers. If Akpabio refuses court orders, Nigeria runs the risk of recurring institutional conflict, undermining public trust in democratic governance.

The suspension of a duly elected senator for such a long period defies democratic expectations. Justice Nyako underscored that depriving constituents of representation violates their political rights. The judgment reaffirmed that the electorate, not parliamentary leadership, is the ultimate arbiter of a representative’s legitimacy.

Akpoti-Uduaghan’s case also spotlights systemic sexism. Her allegations were largely sidelined in favour of procedural enforcement. Critics argue this is reflective of a broader patriarchal structure where women in politics are disproportionately targeted when they challenge established authority.

The Senate Ethics Committee, led by a senator loyal to Akpabio, also came under scrutiny for procedural bias. Critics labeled the hearing less about ethics and more about political retaliation, reinforcing perceptions of legislative impunity.

Now, the Senate must choose between two divergent paths.

Option one is compliance. This involves reinstating Akpoti-Uduaghan, restoring her seat and privileges, and demonstrating respect for judicial oversight. This would not only defuse public anger but also reestablish confidence in the Senate’s democratic values.

Option two is defiance. The Senate could appeal the decision or claim that the judiciary overstepped its bounds. However, such a move would risk further court actions, deepen institutional conflicts, and erode public faith in constitutional rule.

Civil society organizations are watching closely. Already, lawsuits challenging the suspension have been filed in different courts, and several advocacy groups have signaled readiness to escalate the matter, should Akpabio refuse to act.

Immediate compliance with the ruling would signal respect for the rule of law. It would reassert the independence of the judiciary and reinforce the boundaries of legislative power. Moreover, it would help restore public faith in a political system often viewed with suspicion and cynicism.

Defiance, on the other hand, may prompt contempt proceedings, compensation claims, and even legislative crisis. If courts are ignored, it sets a dangerous precedent—one where judicial rulings become optional and democratic accountability collapses under institutional egos.

For Akpabio and the ruling APC, compliance may frustrate hardliners but protect institutional integrity. Defiance could embolden political loyalists but risk a backlash from the electorate, civil society, and the international community.

For the opposition, particularly the PDP, Akpoti-Uduaghan’s reinstatement would be symbolic. It would underscore resistance to legislative overreach and invigorate their narrative on defending constitutional order.

For women in politics, this could become a pivotal moment. A favorable resolution may catalyze gender reforms in parliamentary processes and reduce systemic obstacles faced by women in public life.

This is not the first time Nigeria has witnessed tensions between the judiciary and legislature. The 2017 reinstatement of Senator Ali Ndume and the 2020 victory of Senator Ovie Omo-Agege after their unconstitutional suspensions stand as precedents.

In both cases, the courts ruled that legislative houses do not possess the authority to suspend elected representatives beyond the bounds of constitutional and procedural fairness. These decisions have contributed to a body of jurisprudence affirming the limits of parliamentary immunity.

Justice Nyako’s judgment draws directly from these precedents, reiterating that while legislative bodies may maintain order, their actions must not violate fundamental democratic principles.

Short-term, the Senate must act swiftly. Akpoti-Uduaghan must be reinstated, and she must fulfill the terms of the contempt ruling. Civil society groups remain vigilant, and further protests are likely if the matter is stalled or politicized.

Long-term, the outcome of this case may influence reforms in legislative conduct, judicial accountability, and gender inclusion. It may also provoke constitutional amendments to clarify the limits of legislative disciplinary powers and the scope of judicial review.

Justice Nyako’s decision is more than procedural—it is emblematic of Nigeria’s democratic resilience. Reinstating Akpoti-Uduaghan would affirm the supremacy of the judiciary, uphold the rights of Kogi Central constituents, and send a clear message that elected officials cannot be punished arbitrarily.

But if Senate President Akpabio defies the ruling, it would signal a troubling erosion of institutional checks and balances. It could set Nigeria down a path where political loyalty overrides constitutional fidelity and where the rule of law becomes a casualty of expediency.

As Frederick Douglass reminded us, “Power concedes nothing without a demand.” Here, the courts, civil society, and the public have made that demand. Now it is up to the Senate—and its President—to choose between democratic integrity and institutional defiance.

The reinstatement of one senator may seem minor in the grand scheme. But in moments like this, history is made. Will Nigeria’s democracy rise to the occasion?

Tags: Godswill AkpabioJustice Binta NyakoNatasha Akpoti-Uduaghan
ADVERTISEMENT
Previous Post

Senator Natasha: Nigeria’s Senate President Akpabio Brought To Heel By Legal Checks

Next Post

Major fire shuts part of London Underground causing commuter chaos

You MayAlso Like

Column

Tinubu’s end game on Fubara

July 4, 2025
Featured

The Sheikh Who Conquered Soccer and Coddles Warlords

July 4, 2025
Featured

Trump Plans to Deport Elon Musk and Zohran Mamdani

July 4, 2025
Featured

Senator Natasha: Nigeria’s Senate President Akpabio Brought To Heel By Legal Checks

July 4, 2025
Column

From flood to famine: Rainfall chaos fuels Africa’s drought crisis

July 4, 2025
Column

The Adriana Smith Case Was an Ethical Disaster

June 30, 2025
Next Post

Major fire shuts part of London Underground causing commuter chaos

Trump Plans to Deport Elon Musk and Zohran Mamdani

Discussion about this post

Almost 400 human corpses found piled high in mysterious house of horrors

Senator Natasha: Nigeria’s Senate President Akpabio Brought To Heel By Legal Checks

Are Igbos Cursed Or The Architects Of Their Own Predicament?

Funeral held for woman kept on life support until baby could be delivered

Will Senate President Akpabio Comply with the Court Order and Reinstate Akpoti-Uduaghan?

Goodluck Jonathan Unveils Shocking Truths Behind Nigeria’s Constitutional Crisis During Umaru Musa Yar’Adua’s Prolonged Illness

  • British government apologizes to Peter Obi, as hired impostors, master manipulators on rampage abroad

    1238 shares
    Share 495 Tweet 310
  • Maids trafficked and sold to wealthy Saudis on black market

    1064 shares
    Share 426 Tweet 266
  • Flight Attendant Sees Late Husband On Plane

    966 shares
    Share 386 Tweet 242
  • ‘Céline Dion Dead 2023’: Singer killed By Internet Death Hoax

    901 shares
    Share 360 Tweet 225
  • Crisis echoes, fears grow in Amechi Awkunanaw in Enugu State

    735 shares
    Share 294 Tweet 184
  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest

British government apologizes to Peter Obi, as hired impostors, master manipulators on rampage abroad

April 13, 2023

Maids trafficked and sold to wealthy Saudis on black market

December 27, 2022
Flight Attendant Sees Late Husband On Plane

Flight Attendant Sees Late Husband On Plane

September 22, 2023
‘Céline Dion Dead 2023’: Singer killed By Internet Death Hoax

‘Céline Dion Dead 2023’: Singer killed By Internet Death Hoax

March 21, 2023
Chief Mrs Ebelechukwu, wife of Willie Obiano, former governor of Anambra state

NIGERIA: No, wife of Biafran warlord, Bianca Ojukwu lied – Ebele Obiano:

0

SOUTH AFRICA: TO LEAVE OR NOT TO LEAVE?

0
kelechi iheanacho

TOP SCORER: IHEANACHA

0
Goodluck Ebele Jonathan

WHAT CAN’TBE TAKEN AWAY FROM JONATHAN

0

Tinubu’s end game on Fubara

July 4, 2025

The Sheikh Who Conquered Soccer and Coddles Warlords

July 4, 2025

South Africa’s Former Deputy President, Dies at 64

July 4, 2025

Spiritual Leader Warns: ‘Unburied Corpses Fueling Insecurity in Igbo Land’

July 4, 2025

ABOUT US

Time Africa Magazine

TIME AFRICA MAGAZINE is an African Magazine with a culture of excellence; a magazine without peer. Nearly a third of its readers hold advanced degrees and include novelists, … READ MORE >>

SECTIONS

  • Aviation
  • Column
  • Crime
  • Europe
  • Featured
  • Gallery
  • Health
  • Interviews
  • Israel-Hamas
  • Lifestyle
  • Magazine
  • Middle-East
  • News
  • Politics
  • Press Release
  • Russia-Ukraine
  • Science
  • Special Report
  • Sports
  • TV/Radio
  • UAE
  • UK
  • US
  • World News

Useful Links

  • AllAfrica
  • Channel Africa
  • El Khabar
  • The Guardian
  • Cairo Live
  • Le Republicain
  • Magazine: 9771144975608
  • Subscribe to TIME AFRICA biweekly news magazine

    Enjoy handpicked stories from around African continent,
    delivered anywhere in the world

    Subscribe

    • About Time Africa Magazine
    • Privacy Policy
    • Contact Us
    • WHO’SWHO AWARDS

    © 2025 Time Africa Magazine - All Right Reserved. Time Africa is a trademark of Times Associates, registered in the U.S, & Nigeria. Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Service.

    No Result
    View All Result
    • WHO’SWHO AWARDS
    • Politics
    • Column
    • Interviews
    • Gallery
    • Lifestyle
    • Special Report
    • Sports
    • TV/Radio
    • Aviation
    • Health
    • Science
    • World News

    © 2025 Time Africa Magazine - All Right Reserved. Time Africa is a trademark of Times Associates, registered in the U.S, & Nigeria. Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Service.

    This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.